In case you're willing to shell out a bit more for your lip balm, here's Naturopathica's Sweet Cherry Conditioning Lip Butter ("A luscious lip treatment, featuring a naturally plumping pomegranate-jojoba complex and antioxidant-rich sweet cherry seed oil, deeply conditions to reveal softer, fuller lips"; $22 for 15 ml). I've never tried it but it does seem to get good reviews, and there's a matching lip scrub as well.
A cheap-thrills lemming for National Bittersweet Chocolate Day: Vaseline Cocoa Butter Lip Therapy, promising "an appealing cocoa and vanilla scent" (do comment if you've tried it). $5.99 for 17g at Amazon, probably even cheaper somewhere else, and also sold in a regular lip balm tube.
New from The Body Shop, Swipe It lip balms: "Give your lips some love and add a natural-looking moisturising sheen of colour in one glide with our creamy, easy-to-apply lip balm. Sized for on-the-go, this balm is formulated with 95% nature’s favourite heavy-duty moisturising ingredients, including Community Fair Trade handcrafted shea butter, sustainably-sourced from Ghana. Each balm has a subtle, fruity fragrance with a smooth texture. No excessive shine or tackiness here, just a non-sticky formula that feels creamy and lightweight, leaving lips feeling refreshed." 5g each, available in Blueberry, Kiwi, Dragonfruit, Passionfruit and Strawberry. Looks like maybe these are replacing the Lip Juicers? I don't think these are in the US as of yet, so I don't know the price.
A pink ribbon duo from Aerin: "AERIN is proud to support breast cancer research with a limited-edition Rose Lip Conditioner & Cedar Violet Purse Spray Set. The Rose Lip Conditioner nourishes lips while leaving behind a soft nude finish. Cedar Violet is a luminescent, Floral Woody fragrance that transports you to the wide-open wilderness of the Adirondack Mountains." $58 at Saks for 7 ml of the fragrance and 10 ml of the lip conditioner. You can also find the lip conditioner sold separately; Sephora has it for $35, and there's also a Rose Lip Balm for $35 at Estee Lauder, or a duo of the lip balm plus Amber Musk at Neiman Marcus for $50.
Petit Bunny Gloss Bars ("With a smooth texture that falls somewhere between a lipstick and a lip gloss, this adorable lip crayon is packed with Vitamin E to soften and moisturize lips. Each gloss bar has a different fruity scent and shade, giving lips a natural, sheer color with a high shine glossy finish. This seriously adorable gloss bar can be worn alone or over a tint to add a little extra shine!") come in six colors. They're $8 each for 2g at TonyMoly.