• About
  • Login to comment
    • Facebook
    • RSS
    • Twitter

Now Smell This

a blog about perfume

Menu ▼
  • Perfume Reviews
  • New Perfumes
  • Perfumers
  • Perfume Houses
  • Shop for perfume
  • Resources

The Monday Mail ~ help Susan find a new perfume

Posted by Robin on 24 May 2010 52 Comments

Letterbox

About 20 years ago, Susan started getting blinding headaches from perfume, and so until recently she'd mostly given up wearing scent other than a few essential oils purchased at a local store. Her headaches have abated, and she'd like to find a new signature scent (or two) for daytime. She says she can tell right away if a new fragrance will give her a headache, and it doesn't seem to be related to how light or heavy the perfume is.

Susan doesn't have wonderful access to retail perfume stores, but she's happy to shop online and doesn't mind buying samples. Cost is not a huge factor, but she says she probably wouldn't spend more than $200. She's not after anything trendy, and probably wouldn't buy a celebrity perfume. Here is what we know about Susan:

She's in her early 50s, and owns a small marketing communications company.

She likes things that are quiet, classic, elegant, understated — but not dull or boring.

Her hobbies are gardening ("nothing better than the smell of good dirt"), reading, and old movies, especially the film noir genre of the 30s and 40s.

Before Susan starting getting headaches, she wore Charles of the Ritz (the burgundy bottle). For a time she sort of liked Chanel No. 5, but she decided it's probably too mature for her. Her essential oil scents were Star Jasmine, Green Tea and Habuba (which she says is somewhat African or Middle Eastern-exotic, smoky and kind of chocolate-y). She also likes ginger fragrances (she has several bath/body products in ginger), and jasmine (the right jasmine!) — all of her clothing and linen drawers and closets have Greenleaf Jasmine sachets.

Here is what Susan has tried so far in her search:

D&G Roue de la Fortune: interesting on the card, but horrible on skin, and headache-inducing.

Dior Escale a Pondichery: why bother?

Givenchy Ange ou Demon: nice on the card, but only lasted 30 minutes on skin and turned into a hideous cotton candy. Too young.

Givenchy Ysatis: liked but didn't love.

Bvlgari: she tried quite a few and didn't like any of them, but wants to try Jasmin Noir.

What say you?

Note: top image is Letterbox [cropped] by Roby Ferrari at flickr; some rights reserved.

Filed Under: perfume talk
Tagged With: monday mail

Advertisement


52 Comments

Leave a comment, or read more about commenting at Now Smell This. Here's our privacy policy, and a handy emoticon chart.

  1. March says:
    24 May 2010 at 10:17 am

    Blech. I say, Susan, get out of the mall! She seems to me to like scents that have a more botanical (avoiding the word “natural”) vibe. I think she should go on the Dawn Spencer Hurwitz website and order herself some samples. DSH does faux-retro nicely, and has a lot of what I think of as “spa” scents — green tea, ginger, etc. She also has a newer line of actual botanicals, although I’m not suggesting they’re “natural” as I have no idea.

    Log in to Reply
    • lemonprint says:
      24 May 2010 at 1:16 pm

      I agree – though something more abstract than strict botanicals might be called for, to give it more of a “perfume” feel than just a botanical scent. I was thinking of Untitled No. 3 by Sarah Horowitz – affordable, an oil (as it may be some things in alcohol-based spritzes that are causing the headaches), a lovely unfolding experience but one that ends in a gently sweet perfume that is not like everything else but could still feel classic.

      Or, similarly, something from Ava Luxe – if she likes a certain level of sweetness and florals, then Citrine (a vanilla citrus) or Roses (a glorious blend of all types of roses) might just suit!

      Log in to Reply
      • March says:
        24 May 2010 at 9:38 pm

        I like your suggestions. I’m a little late back here, but I felt, as a fellow migraine-sufferer, a headache coming on at the thought of Angie Demon and the D&Gs, etc. I’m thinking something less in-your-face would be good.

        Log in to Reply
  2. Robin says:
    24 May 2010 at 10:21 am

    A possibility: Annick Goutal Le Jasmin, which has jasmine and ginger.

    Log in to Reply
    • March says:
      24 May 2010 at 9:39 pm

      Dangit, WHERE is my mini of that?!? Now you’ve reminded me I’m cross again!! Those used to be so easy to find online too!

      Log in to Reply
  3. Suzanne941 says:
    24 May 2010 at 10:34 am

    Might be a good Jo Malone candidate. They make a lot of lovely scents with a similar botanical vibe and are understated. And I’d definitely check out some sample packs from L’Artisan….Tea for Two and L’Haie Fleurie popped into mind.

    Log in to Reply
    • March says:
      24 May 2010 at 9:36 pm

      Seconding the Jo Malone … maybe White Jasmine and Mint? Plus they layer nicely.

      Log in to Reply
  4. Zazie says:
    24 May 2010 at 10:38 am

    here are a few suggestions…
    As a refined wink to her n°5 previous loving self:
    *Chanel 31 Rue Cambon
    *Chanel Bois des iles
    heavy on the Ginger (and on the wallet)
    *Sisley eau 3
    For her jasmin green tea fix
    *L’artisan parfumeur Thé pour une été
    If Susan hasn’t tried Shalimar, a huge hit or miss, I find it along the lines of her description of the exotic and smoky essential oil she favours. maybe Guerlain Tonka Imperiale could be along those “heavier” lines of thought, too?
    Good luck Susan, have fun sampling! ;)

    Log in to Reply
    • Bee says:
      24 May 2010 at 11:07 am

      joining in: DO try the Chanel exclusives (especially 31 rC)! Did you really try Bvlgari Blv, the lighter version? , it is quite gingery…. One seldom mentioned scent it Cerrutti’s 1881 for woman, I used to love it, stopped when a co-worker started to wear it, but it could fit your profile.

      Log in to Reply
    • miss kitty v. says:
      24 May 2010 at 11:21 am

      Seconding Bois des Iles.

      Log in to Reply
  5. elise says:
    24 May 2010 at 10:56 am

    I 2nd bois de Iles! And Bulgaria jasmine nuit is quite nice. I’d try a sniff of Ferre just for fun and take a sniff of the new LArtisan nuit de Tuberose…and Chanels Bel Respiro might interest you as well!

    Log in to Reply
    • OperaFan says:
      24 May 2010 at 2:29 pm

      Again, the mention of Ferre! If I haven’t overshot my perfume and cosmetics budget by three-folds this quarter, I’d probably have plopped down the $20 it takes to buy the 1oz bottle on evilbay. Will have to rectify once the 2nd qtr damages clear….

      Log in to Reply
  6. boojum says:
    24 May 2010 at 10:56 am

    I’ll second the The Pour un Ete. Also suggest Chanel Bel Respiro, Profumum Victrix, MPG Baime, and AG Mandragore. All these strike me as simple but not boring, and fall into the green/tea/jasmine ranges she seems to like.

    Log in to Reply
    • odonata9 says:
      24 May 2010 at 2:03 pm

      I’ll third the The Pour un Ete. It’s lovely and I’m considering a full bottle purchase of this myself. Also would recommend Hermes Osmanthe Yunnan.

      Log in to Reply
      • Haunani says:
        24 May 2010 at 8:25 pm

        Second Osmanthe Yunnan. That one’s lovely!

        Log in to Reply
  7. Daisy says:
    24 May 2010 at 10:59 am

    I agree with Zazie–the first thing that popped into my head was Sisley Eau de Sisley #3 which is usually at discounters for a decent price.
    I wonder how Chanel Cristalle eau Verte or Bel Respiro would do since it’s summer and they don’t (at least to me ) have an “age” like some of the classics do. I also wondered about Chamade…but I love Chamade so it’s always right there on the tip of my tongue to suggest. And Bois des Iles might be another to try. As for liking the good rich smell of soil…..Penhaligon’s Bluebell smells just like damp soil to me, and CBIHP violet empire has a good dose of “gardening” in it too.

    Log in to Reply
    • elise says:
      24 May 2010 at 11:52 am

      I love chamade as well! And how about another penhaligons: amaranthine!

      Log in to Reply
  8. kaos.geo says:
    24 May 2010 at 11:03 am

    As usual here’s my oddball recommendation:

    Very Irrésistible for Men by Givenchy

    They describe it as a gourmand chocolatey-coffee concoction…

    But for me it smells of dirt… unearthed coffee beans.

    Log in to Reply
    • kaos.geo says:
      24 May 2010 at 11:04 am

      And I KNOW it is a man’s fragrance… but a woman, specially one that likes the smell of dirt, could certainly pull it off!

      Log in to Reply
      • sll says:
        24 May 2010 at 4:01 pm

        Hi there — I’m the Susan referenced in this piece. I just had to comment on your suggestion — most of my mother’s favorite scents were men’s fragrances.

        Log in to Reply
    • Rictor07 says:
      24 May 2010 at 12:19 pm

      To me, hazelnut is the most pronounced note of Very Irresistible for Men.

      Log in to Reply
      • kaos.geo says:
        24 May 2010 at 2:07 pm

        It is really puzzling that people have so many differents reactions to this one.

        Either it has something that is interpreted very subjectively by each person or the formulation is very unstable! (unlikely, I know, but I cannot find another logical explanation)

        Log in to Reply
  9. Antje says:
    24 May 2010 at 11:07 am

    I might be stating the obvious, but what about Chanel N5 Eau Premiere?
    Some others that might be interesting and read classic/elegant to me:
    OJ Woman
    Guerlain Cruel Gardenia
    JHAG Citizen Queen

    Log in to Reply
    • Daisy says:
      24 May 2010 at 11:21 am

      oh yum —Cruel Gardenia —nice pick

      Log in to Reply
      • boojum says:
        24 May 2010 at 12:13 pm

        Ha, I’ll “oh yum” the OTHER two. ;)

        Log in to Reply
        • Daisy says:
          25 May 2010 at 9:28 am

          all of my Guerlains just simultaneously stuck out their perfume-bottle-tongues at you…..

          Log in to Reply
  10. orage says:
    24 May 2010 at 11:12 am

    Tocca Bianca- it’s very fresh, floral, maybe a bit sweet though, I’m pretty sure there’s jasmine and green tea in there
    Ralph Lauren Romance- I know there’s ginger, but more to the point it kind of fits the “quiet, classic, elegant, understated” idea I think.
    Demeter Wet Garden- Just because she enjoys the smell of dirt and gardening and I thought suggesting Dirt would be too obvious.
    Marc Jacobs- Just cause it’s so lovely and also there’s the ginger

    Log in to Reply
    • lemonprint says:
      24 May 2010 at 1:17 pm

      I second the Tocca idea, though Stella is my favorite.

      Log in to Reply
    • dollydagger says:
      24 May 2010 at 2:46 pm

      Love Bianca, especially for summer, although it’s more grapefruit than green tea.

      Log in to Reply
  11. miss kitty v. says:
    24 May 2010 at 11:20 am

    Give ELdO’s Vraie Blonde a try. Even though I don’t think ginger or chocolate are listed as notes, I think it has a ginger ale fizz to it. (The fizz being the champagne note, which doesn’t smell very champagne-y to me.) I oddly don’t always get chocolate from it, and when I do it doesn’t last, but that might vary from person to person.

    Log in to Reply
  12. georgia says:
    24 May 2010 at 11:47 am

    Definately try L’Artisan’s The pour un ete. Lovely jasmine green tea.
    I’m wearing it today…

    Log in to Reply
    • georgia says:
      24 May 2010 at 12:01 pm

      Hermes, Osmanthe Yunnan is also a quiet beautiful light floral with notes of green tea, worth a try…

      Log in to Reply
  13. Dixie says:
    24 May 2010 at 12:12 pm

    For Jasmine Le De by Givenchy or Jojo by Liz Zorn (Soivohle).

    Feminite du Bois-just because.

    For Exotic-Amouage Tribute Attar (expensive, I know)
    -Bois Farine-more smokey
    -Iris Oriental by Parfumerie Generale
    -Fragonard Cette Nuit La
    -Sutra Ylang by Bois 1920
    Good Luck!

    Log in to Reply
  14. Robin R. says:
    24 May 2010 at 12:23 pm

    Hello, Susan!

    I hope that you’ll visit the Ayala Moriel website. She’s from Vancouver, quite well-known in perfumista circles, and does lots of mail-order business. Her scents are natural and often lean to the botanical, and stylistically I think they’re exactly the kind of thing you would love. They’re classically-inspired but modern and original, and she’s got an unusually large roster to chose from.

    There is a sample program and the website gives lots of information on the composition of each scent at a glance, so it’s really easy to pick out some promising candidates. She’s a one-woman company, too, so I’m sure you’d get personal service if you contacted her through the site and asked her for suggestions.

    Just to give you an idea of the kinds of things she’s doing, and one that you might really like, is her Champaca Chai, with ginger, Assam tea, jasmine and champaca flowers.

    Good luck and have fun. You have lots of other good suggestions here and your biggest problem will be having the chance to explore them all. ;-)

    Log in to Reply
    • Dixie says:
      24 May 2010 at 12:36 pm

      Her Film Noir is nice. It’s all base notes and it has chocolate.

      Log in to Reply
    • Dixie says:
      24 May 2010 at 12:37 pm

      And the Espionage has a nice smokiness to it,

      Log in to Reply
      • Robin R. says:
        24 May 2010 at 3:03 pm

        Mmmmm, yes.

        Log in to Reply
  15. lemonprint says:
    24 May 2010 at 1:20 pm

    I see several people recommending tea fragrances – one of my favorites is Element of Surprise by Creative Universe. It is affordable (even more so if you find some on eBay!) and lasts surprisingly well for such a light scent. A beautiful combination of tea and florals, including apparently jasmine. One of my favorite summer perfumes!

    Log in to Reply
    • boojum says:
      24 May 2010 at 1:45 pm

      Oh, second this one as well. It really is a nice one!

      Log in to Reply
  16. maggiecat says:
    24 May 2010 at 3:28 pm

    I second (third?) Tocca Bianca. Chanel Cristalle Eau Verte might also be a good one to try, and I liked what I’ve sampled of Armani Code Eau Fraiche (the new Summer version). And the Cloe Eaux de Fleurs, especially Capucine, might also be good possibilities. Good luck Susan!

    Log in to Reply
  17. sll says:
    24 May 2010 at 4:03 pm

    Hi all — what a wealth of great suggestions you’ve given me. Looks like I’ll be placing a healthy sample order somewhere! Thanks so much. — Susan

    Log in to Reply
  18. Thea S. says:
    24 May 2010 at 4:22 pm

    hmmm. I got an immediate Chanel Coromandel vibe from the description of Susan. When I first heard of Coromandel on Katie Pukricks channel @ Youtube I think she first described it as the smell of good clean dirt. I’ve tried Jasmin Noir and Eau Premier and feel like they share a similar note or feel within them, there’s some sort of luxurious tone to them all but I feel like Coromandel is the most interesting. Definitely worth trying!! Sorry I can’t recommend any jasmine or tea perfs, I haven’t met any that I liked enough yet.

    Log in to Reply
  19. Joe says:
    24 May 2010 at 7:46 pm

    Parfumerie Generale Drama Nuui.

    Or, on the lower end of the price spectrum: L’Occitane Green Tea & Jasmine.

    Log in to Reply
  20. olenska says:
    24 May 2010 at 7:54 pm

    I would recommend Parfumerie Generale’s Iris Taizo– it is quiet, stays close to the skin, and has a pronounced xocolatl streak to appeal to Susan’s love for smoke/spice/chocolate.

    Log in to Reply
    • Robin R. says:
      24 May 2010 at 8:43 pm

      Beautifully described, olenska. It’s lovely because it has that rich, smooth quality but it’s low-key and not at all sweet. I’d love some myself. ;-)

      Log in to Reply
    • Dixie says:
      24 May 2010 at 11:46 pm

      I love this one. Now they call it Iris Oriental-I don’t know why. I think Taizo is better.

      Log in to Reply
  21. 50_Roses says:
    24 May 2010 at 10:00 pm

    I just tried Ormonde Jayne Woman, and my first impression was of being outside in my garden, planting shrubs. I got the scent of earth, leaves, fresh air, and just a little bit of flowers in bloom. My second thought was of standing in a forest. As a fellow classic-loving, old film-watching gardener, I recommend it.

    Log in to Reply
  22. lilydale aka Natalie says:
    24 May 2010 at 10:12 pm

    Tons of great suggestions above, Susan, but I can’t believe no one mentioned Serge Lutens 5 o’clock au Gingembre! It doesn’t work on me, but it’s probably a must-try for ginger and tea fans. Also, for some odd reason Cumming came to mind — probably because of your predilection for dirt! It’s a wonderful Scotch + peat + dirt scent.

    Log in to Reply
  23. DJ says:
    25 May 2010 at 4:46 am

    Hiris!

    Quiet, elegant… and a teeny touch of dirt.

    Log in to Reply
    • Daisy says:
      25 May 2010 at 9:30 am

      Hiris–also a great iris scent for summer; it always seems chilly to me.

      Log in to Reply
  24. Lovetosmell says:
    25 May 2010 at 9:10 am

    I have the same problem so much so that I had to refrain from wearing perfumes.But, I discovered perfume oils again and notice that I can wear them without getting headaches .Try perfume oils you can order samples from etailers and test them out.You can even get no 5 in an oil version.

    Log in to Reply
  25. TallulahRose says:
    25 May 2010 at 3:49 pm

    The first scents that popped into mind are classics, and fit the elegant, understated and yet never boring description in the brief:

    -Le Parfum de Therèse, which is quite classic, but still quite unusual;

    -Joy, which has the gorgeous florals and none of the aldehydes of Chanel No. 5;

    – Patou 1000.

    I also though immediately of the perfumes of Mona di Orio, which make me think of film noir and the classics… the most obvious is Nuit Noir, which has a beautiful ginger note, flowers and spices. A less obvious suggestion is Carnation, which seems rather proper and traditional, but is a sexy skin scent.

    Log in to Reply

Leave a reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Advertisement


Luckyscent

Search

Browse by…

Topic

Perfume talk New fragrances
Shopping Books :: News
Body products Home fragrance
Polls Another subject

Date

December 2020
November 2020
October 2020
September 2020
August 2020
July 2020
Prior months

Author

Robin Jessica
Angela Kevin
Erin Guest Author

Tag

Celebrity perfumes
Cheap thrills
Collector bottles
Perfumista tip series
Video
The complete tag index

From NST at Twitter

  • Headline of the day: "Gwyneth Paltrow’s vagina-scented candle almost burns down home of woman who won it in a quiz" https://t.co/F6bvZtoSXl,
  • "Jo Loves adopts refillable technology for Fragrance Paintbrush" (cosmeticsbusiness) https://t.co/sn2tZ1cguT,
  • @robini71 And my favorite honeysuckle is also limited edition -- Goutal Le Chevrefeuille. They do bring it back eve… https://t.co/MFGwHJK0Ji,

Recent reviews

Atelier Cologne Love Osmanthus
Moschino Toy Boy
Arquiste Misfit
Diptyque Eau Capitale
Zoologist Bee
Parfum d’Empire Immortelle Corse
Comme des Garcons Series 10 Clash
Frédéric Malle Rose & Cuir
L’Artisan Parfumeur Le Chant de Camargue
Yves Saint Laurent Grain de Poudre
Régime des Fleurs Chloë Sevigny Little Flower
Chanel 1957
Gallivant Los Angeles
Amouage Portrayal Woman

Blogroll

Bois de Jasmin
Grain de Musc
Perfume Posse
The Non-Blonde
More blogs...

Perfumista lists

100 fragrances every perfumista should try
And 25 more fragrances every perfumista should smell
50 masculine fragrances every perfumista should try
26 vintage fragrances every perfumista should try
25 rose fragrances every perfumista should try
11 Cheap Perfumes Beauty Outsiders Love

Favorite posts

The Great Perfume Reduction Plan
Why I Love Old School Chypres
New to perfume and want to learn more?
How to make fragrance last through the day
Fragrance concentrations: sorting it all out
On reformulations, or why your favorite perfume doesn’t smell like it used to
How to get fragrance samples
Perfume for Life: How Long Will Your Fragrance Collection Last?

Upcoming

List of upcoming Friday projects

TBA April ~ freebiemeet

Back to Top

Home
About Now Smell This :: Privacy Policy

Shop for Perfume Online
Perfume Shopping in New York
Perfume Shopping in London
Perfume Reviews
New Perfumes
General Perfume Articles
The Monday Mail

Glossary of Perfume Terms
Perfume FAQ
Perfume Links
Perfume Books
Fragrance Awards

Noses ~ Perfumers A-E :: F-K :: L-S :: T-Z

Perfume Houses A-B :: C :: D-E :: F-G
H-J :: K-L :: M :: N-O :: P :: Q-R :: S
T :: U-Z

Copyright © 2005-2021 Now Smell This. All rights reserved.