• About
  • Login to comment
    • Facebook
    • RSS
    • Twitter

Now Smell This

a blog about perfume

Menu ▼
  • Perfume Reviews
  • New Perfumes
  • Perfumers
  • Perfume Houses
  • Shop for perfume
  • Resources

Maison Martin Margiela Replica Whispers in the Library ~ fragrance review

Posted by Jessica on 1 August 2019 16 Comments

Whispers in the Library is a recent addition to the Maison Martin Margiela Replica fragrance collection; it "evokes the memory of a mysterious library made of antique woodwork perfectly waxed. The slowing down of time between books and the whispers of turning pages." Its remembered or imagined setting is "Oxford 1997" and it's categorized as an "oriental woody" scent for men or women.

I've spent a significant portion of my adult life in libraries — in graduate school, during dissertation research, and in various jobs — and I love the idea of a perfume inspired by libraries and old books. However, it's already been done. In 2012 Kevin reviewed two perfumes for book-lovers, Wallpaper/Steidl Paper Passion and CB I Hate Perfume's In the Library. (I'm very fond of the latter, dating back to 2000, "a warm blend of English Novel, Russian and Moroccan leather bindings, worn cloth and a hint of wood polish.") At the high-priced niche end of the spectrum, we also have Byredo Bibliothèque; at the affordable end, Demeter Paperback; somewhere in the middle, Commodity Book.

So, what does Whispers in the Library bring to the (book-stacked) table? Its listed notes are black pepper, cedar and vanilla. It starts off slightly boozy and androgynous. The pepper gives the smooth cedar an edge. The vanilla accord is mild, initially, and it later becomes more prominent and takes on a maltier quality. Whispers in the Library begins as a piquant woody blend and ends up as a quiet gourmand, more conventionally feminine than it was in its opening stages. The vanilla is there for a thematic reasons, I'm guessing: in 2011 the International League of Antiquarian Booksellers shared the results of a 2009 scientific study about the smell of old books, revealing that the organic polymer lignin, "which is present in all wood-based paper, is closely related to vanillin. As it breaks down, the lignin grants old books that faint vanilla scent.” (Or maybe someone just thought that this fragrance would sell better if it had a vanilla note somewhere in the mix?)

Whispers in the Library has low sillage and average longevity on my skin. It feels a bit "front-loaded," starting off competently enough and then losing my interest. It would be suitable for the office or, yes, even the library; but why bother, when there are already earlier and stronger variations on this theme? For me, there isn't anything particularly wrong about the Replica fragrances. But why bother with Lipstick On when you could have Lipstick Rose, or spend time on Funfair Evening when you could enjoy 4160Tuesdays What I Did on My Holidays, etc., etc.?  Perhaps I'm not the target audience — but as someone who loves perfume and libraries, I can't help having an opinion on this one.

Maison Martin Margiela Whispers in the Library is available as 100 ml ($126) or 10 ml ($28) Eau de Toilette.

Possibly of interest

Maison Margiela Matcha Meditation ~ new fragrance
Maison Margiela Bubble Bath ~ new fragrance
Maison Margiela Coffee Break & Springtime in a Park ~ new fragrances

Filed Under: perfume talk
Tagged With: martin margiela

Advertisement


16 Comments

Leave a comment, or read more about commenting at Now Smell This. Here's our privacy policy, and a handy emoticon chart.

  1. BigslyFragrance says:
    1 August 2019 at 2:25 pm

    It feels, these days, like we’ve gone from variations on a theme to variations on variations on a theme!

    Log in to Reply
    • Jessica says:
      1 August 2019 at 2:34 pm

      Hah, yes! You’d think there was nothing new under the sun…

      Log in to Reply
  2. monkeytoe says:
    1 August 2019 at 3:15 pm

    Thank you for the review–I agree with you, none of the Replica series have tugged at my wallet, but I give them a sniff when I run across them because of the promise of the names and themes.

    One of my favorite library scents is l”Artisan Dzing!, though it may be better thought of as a used bookstore scent with its leather, a bit of vanilla sweetness from the benzoin, woody cedar, a hint of fur from the shop cat or dog and the musk of a too rarely washed overcoat hung near the door.

    Log in to Reply
    • Jessica says:
      1 August 2019 at 4:02 pm

      Dzing! is so wonderfully odd.

      I’ve sniffed many of the Replicas by now, and some of them are nice to wear for a day or two, but then I just keep thinking of something that I like *more.* It’s sort of like seeing a just-alright film adaptation of a book you love…you want to go experience the “original” again.

      Log in to Reply
  3. dramalydia says:
    1 August 2019 at 4:48 pm

    Thank you for your review; you are unfailingly kind, regardless of your opinion on a scent. You are right: the Replica series is a nice-but-why-bother line. I have not smelled Mutiny, but I do enjoy the sharp snap of Untitled l’Eau. Re Dzing!, I had it inside one elbow and Timbuktu inside the other while watching the first night of the debates. It was a close race, but Timbuktu won.

    Log in to Reply
    • Jessica says:
      1 August 2019 at 4:54 pm

      I’m more fond of Untitled, too! I thought it was discontinued, but apparently not.

      I like the pencil-shaving note in Timbuktu. I still have a few favorites from L’Artisan…

      Yeah, maybe this line is a gateway for people who don’t know about niche and independent fragrance yet, but the overall concept *and* most of the scents are derivative…

      Log in to Reply
  4. Glannys says:
    1 August 2019 at 5:36 pm

    I like By the Fireplace and have recently bought a decant of it. If there is a similar scent but better, I do not know it.

    I tried Lipstick on a few months ago, and though I can’t say I loved it, I quite enjoyed it and did not think of it as Lipstick Rose clone. Will need to try it again before the final verdict though. I admit that I am going through a ‘lipstick scent junkie’ phase, so I kind of collect the samples of this genre at the moment. :)

    Log in to Reply
    • Jessica says:
      1 August 2019 at 5:52 pm

      Lipstick On also reminded me a little of the Chloe fragrance with the rice-powder note… It’s ok but it didn’t last long on me!

      Log in to Reply
      • Filomena says:
        2 August 2019 at 11:03 am

        None of the Replica fragrances last on me. They do copy other fragrances (thus the name Replica?).

        Log in to Reply
        • Jessica says:
          2 August 2019 at 11:19 am

          That name makes me laugh, too. Supposedly they’re “bottling” memories and thus “replicating” them, but…

          ;)

          Log in to Reply
          • gunmetal24 says:
            3 August 2019 at 6:40 pm

            The term replica is frequently used across their fashion line. Its part of their brand. I’m not sure what it means exactly though. I know the famous Margiela sneakers are a replica of the old style german sneakers…not sure if its an exact replica or a reinterpretation or something else.

  5. hajusuuri says:
    1 August 2019 at 6:24 pm

    Have you tried Mad et Len Perit Papiers?

    Log in to Reply
    • Jessica says:
      1 August 2019 at 6:30 pm

      No!! I’ll keep an eye out for it!

      Log in to Reply
    • Oakland Fresca says:
      1 August 2019 at 7:25 pm

      I love that perfume. Don’t own it, but kept my sample dauber bottle to remind me that it is a goody.

      Log in to Reply
  6. AnnieA says:
    2 August 2019 at 2:02 am

    This line has always left me cold, and you have pinpointed why. Also. the labels are dull…

    Log in to Reply
    • Jessica says:
      2 August 2019 at 11:20 am

      Other brands have been doing the “typed” label look for a while…CBIHP, Le Labo…

      Log in to Reply

Leave a reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Advertisement


Luckyscent

Search

Browse by…

Topic

Perfume talk New fragrances
Shopping Books :: News
Body products Home fragrance
Polls Another subject

Date

December 2020
November 2020
October 2020
September 2020
August 2020
July 2020
Prior months

Author

Robin Jessica
Angela Kevin
Erin Guest Author

Tag

Celebrity perfumes
Cheap thrills
Collector bottles
Perfumista tip series
Video
The complete tag index

From NST at Twitter

  • "How French perfumer Frédéric Malle conquered the sophisticated world of fragrance" (options) https://t.co/EfHtUkBWob,
  • Headline of the day: "Gwyneth Paltrow’s vagina-scented candle almost burns down home of woman who won it in a quiz" https://t.co/F6bvZtoSXl,

Recent reviews

Atelier Cologne Love Osmanthus
Moschino Toy Boy
Arquiste Misfit
Diptyque Eau Capitale
Zoologist Bee
Parfum d’Empire Immortelle Corse
Comme des Garcons Series 10 Clash
Frédéric Malle Rose & Cuir
L’Artisan Parfumeur Le Chant de Camargue
Yves Saint Laurent Grain de Poudre
Régime des Fleurs Chloë Sevigny Little Flower
Chanel 1957
Gallivant Los Angeles
Amouage Portrayal Woman

Blogroll

Bois de Jasmin
Grain de Musc
Perfume Posse
The Non-Blonde
More blogs...

Perfumista lists

100 fragrances every perfumista should try
And 25 more fragrances every perfumista should smell
50 masculine fragrances every perfumista should try
26 vintage fragrances every perfumista should try
25 rose fragrances every perfumista should try
11 Cheap Perfumes Beauty Outsiders Love

Favorite posts

The Great Perfume Reduction Plan
Why I Love Old School Chypres
New to perfume and want to learn more?
How to make fragrance last through the day
Fragrance concentrations: sorting it all out
On reformulations, or why your favorite perfume doesn’t smell like it used to
How to get fragrance samples
Perfume for Life: How Long Will Your Fragrance Collection Last?

Upcoming

List of upcoming Friday projects

TBA April ~ freebiemeet

Back to Top

Home
About Now Smell This :: Privacy Policy

Shop for Perfume Online
Perfume Shopping in New York
Perfume Shopping in London
Perfume Reviews
New Perfumes
General Perfume Articles
The Monday Mail

Glossary of Perfume Terms
Perfume FAQ
Perfume Links
Perfume Books
Fragrance Awards

Noses ~ Perfumers A-E :: F-K :: L-S :: T-Z

Perfume Houses A-B :: C :: D-E :: F-G
H-J :: K-L :: M :: N-O :: P :: Q-R :: S
T :: U-Z

Copyright © 2005-2021 Now Smell This. All rights reserved.